Unit 5: Engaging in Debate Time Frame: 4 Weeks
Objectives | Skill Focus | Instructional Strategies | Activities/Assessments |
· Students will practice developing their own writing style and voice.
· Students will refine original arguments, counterarguments, and concession.
· Students will refine commentary skills.
· Student will practice revision and reflection about their own composition.
· Students will practice multiple- choice skills. |
· Close Reading
· Developing Authorial Voice and Style
· Refining Original Argument
· Refining Counterargument and Concession
· Building Archival/Outside Knowledge
· Synthesizing Information |
· Assign nonfiction that supports deep understanding of argumentation.
· Model strategies that developing writing style and voice.
· Model counterargument and concession strategies.
· Model revising/refining composition skills. |
· Close Reading Exercises
· Synthesis Exercises
· Researched Writing Assignments
· Argumentation Exercises
· Moral/Ethical Dilemma Exercises
· Counterargument and Concession Exercises |
Texts
- Fast Food Nation, Eric Schlosser
- The Omnivore’s Dilemma, Michael Pollan
- Nickel and Dimed, Barbara Ehrenreich
- Nim Chimpsky: The Chimp Who Would Be Human, Elizabeth Hess
- The Good Soldiers, David Finkel
o Mature Language and Situations
Unit
- The American Consumer
- The Effects of War
- Nature vs. Man
Lessons and Resources
Below is a list of possible lessons for a unit that focuses understanding building student voice, style, and argument.
- Ask the Ethicist Lessons
- Counterargument/Concession Exercises
- Researched Writing Assignment
- Synthesis Deconstruction Lesson
- Multiple Choice Rationales and Error Logs
Multiple Choice
- Democracy in America, Alexis de Tocqueville (14 Questions)
- Key and Rationales
- “Speech to Parliament,” Queen Elizabeth I (13 Questions)
- Key and Rationales
Free Response Questions.
Rhetorical Analysis
2004 Form B, Question 1
- Silent Spring, Rachel Carson
- Student Samples
- Scoring Commentary
Argument
2002 Form A, Question 3
- “Testament’s Betrayed,” Milan Kundera
- Area of Focus: Public vs. Private Behavior
- Student Samples
- Scoring Commentary
Synthesis
2011 Form B, Question 1
- Green Living
- Area of Focus: Should the Government Foster Green Practices?
Student Samples and Commentary
AP Language Unit Five Calendar
The following calendar offers one approach for structuring an AP Language course. The activities below are not exhaustive, but they are suggestions to help teachers think about how to sequence the skills and content students need for AP English success.
Weeks Five and Six (in a nine-week grading cycle): Understanding the Debate
- Ask the Ethicist Assignments
- Close Reading Exercises and Argumentation Exercises
- Argument Prompt Deconstruction and Writing
- Composition Strategies and Prompt Deconstruction Lessons
- Multiple Choice Assessment
Weeks Seven and Eight: Engaging in the Debate
- Researched Writing Assignments
- Argument Prompt Exercise
- Synthesis Prompt Creation
- Close Reading Exercises and Argumentation Exercises
Assessment
Rhetorical Analysis
2004 Form B
- Silent Spring, Rachel Carson
Argument
2002 Form A
- “Testament’s Betrayed,” Milan Kundera
- Area of Focus: Public vs. Private Behavior